| Platinum | Taqueria El Rey |
| Gold | Vallarta Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | El Rey Tex Mex |
| Bronze | El Kiosco Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Diablos Southwest Grill |
| Top Pick | Mi Casita |
| Top Pick | Poblanos |
| Top Pick | Tacocat |
| Top Pick | Taqueria El Patron |
| Top Pick | Victoria's Mexican Restaurant |