| Platinum | Southern Fired Foods |
| Gold | Oliviana's |
| Silver | Antonio's Italian Eatery |
| Bronze | The Pizza Joint |
| Top Pick | Armando's Grill & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Augustino's Italian Eatery and Prime Steaks |
| Top Pick | Luigi's |
| Top Pick | Pizza Central |
| Top Pick | Sbarro |
| Top Pick | Villa Europa |