| Platinum | Harlem Java House |
| Gold | Goat Kick Coffee |
| Gold | Rooted Coffeehouse |
| Silver | 7 Brew Coffee |
| Bronze | Metro Coffeehouse and Pub |
| Top Pick | Buona Caffe Artisan Rosted Coffee |
| Top Pick | Lazarette St. Bakeshop |
| Top Pick | New Moon Cafe |
| Top Pick | SuzieQ's |
| Top Pick | Trellis |