| Platinum | The Morbid Morsels |
| Platinum | Two Mom's Cookies |
| Gold | Crumbl Cookies |
| Silver | Mason's Shaken Lemonade |
| Bronze | Whipped Creamery |
| Top Pick | A Piece of Cake Bakery |
| Top Pick | Edgar's Bakehouse |
| Top Pick | Krazykakes Catering by Danielle |
| Top Pick | Lazarette St. Bakeshop |
| Top Pick | Main Street Treats |