| Platinum | Sheehan's Irish Pub |
| Gold | Abel Brown Southern Kitchen & Oyster Bar |
| Silver | Calvert's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Finch & Fifth |
| Top Pick | Cadwalladers Café |
| Top Pick | Cork and Flame |
| Top Pick | Craft and Vine |
| Top Pick | Edgar's Grille |
| Top Pick | Frog Hollow Tavern |
| Top Pick | The Pinnacle Club |