| Platinum | Kid to Kid Evans |
| Gold | Uptown Cheapskate |
| Silver | Encore Boutique & Consignments |
| Bronze | Second Time Around |
| Top Pick | Attic Treasures |
| Top Pick | Catholic Social Services Thrift Shop |
| Top Pick | Don'T Toss It |
| Top Pick | Goodwill Retail Store |
| Top Pick | The Memory Exchange |
| Top Pick | Top Dog Pawn |