| Platinum | Orange Otter Toys Store |
| Gold | HobbyTown |
| Silver | Build-a-Bear Workshop |
| Bronze | A Doll's World |
| Top Pick | Catholic Social Services Thrift Shop |
| Top Pick | Cuddles and Carriages |
| Top Pick | Five Below |
| Top Pick | Many Moons Boutique |
| Top Pick | Uptown Marketplace |
| Top Pick | Walmart |